Call Us 0161 832 4036     |     Public Access Enquiry
;

Josephine Scally Secures Five-Figure Payout in Credit Hire Case

Josephine Scally | September 16, 2026

Josephine Scally secured an excellent result for a Credit Hire client whose car smashed into a Subway shop when another car collided with it.

The client was parked at a BP petrol station on 02/10/2025 when the defendant collided with their parked, unattended vehicle. The impact sent their car into the sandwich storefront, damaging it beyond repair.

The vehicle was later recovered on 04/10/2025 and was stored until 21/10/2025.

The vehicle was deemed a total loss by an independent Engineer who was instructed on 13/10/2025, carried out a desktop review on 15/10/2025, and submitted their report, recommending that the vehicle be moved to safe storage because of sharp edges and loose parts making it a public safety issue.

The independent Engineer’s report was then sent to the third-party insurer on 16/10/2025, who made payment equal to the pre-accident value of the car (£1,155.63) on 24/10/2025.

The claimant then hired a replacement vehicle on a credit basis to the eventual sum of £8,630.40.

Josephine Scally used the claimant’s witness statement, monitoring notes and engineering evidence in relation to the period of hire of the replacement vehicle to prove that they acted reasonably in their decision to get the replacement vehicle on a Credit Hire basis.

The period of hire ended on 10/11/2025, and the claimant purchased a replacement vehicle on 26/11/2026 after receiving the pre-accident value of the car payment.

At their defence on 23/02/2026, the defendant admitted liability.

Credit Hire Barrister Josephine Scally was instructed by Malik Tijani at Winn Solicitors to represent the client at a hearing and recover costs for damage suffered, the value of the car, the hire cost of a replacement car, recovery and storage costs, and travel expenses.

She provided communication with counsel both before and after the hearing utilising her vast experience in handling issues that commonly arise in Credit Hire cases.

Her highly detailed brief to counsel addressed the complexity of the case and was thorough in detailing what arguments the defendant may bring and providing counter-arguments along with all the relevant case law in prior Credit Hire cases.

At the hearing, the judgment was entered in full for the client. The damages were equal to £11,083.99, credit for the pre-accident value of the car (which was a write-off) equal to £1,155.63, costs (Solicitor’s fixed costs, issue fee, hearing fee) equal to £1000.19, and expenses (witness expenses, such as travel expenses) equal to £71.70. This totalled over £13k and marked a big win for Winn Solicitors and Credit Hire expert Josephine Scally.

Malik Tijani said, “Thank you so much to Josephine Scally for this excellent result. The advice she provided before the hearing was invaluable, drawing our focus towards the issues that complicated the case, especially in relation to impecuniosity and financial disclosure. Her communication with counsel is always of the very highest standard.”

As an experienced advocate with over two decades of experience, Josephine Scally prides herself on supplying strategic advice in Credit Hire cases. If you have a Credit Hire case you need advice or advocacy for, call our Civil Clerks Michael Jones and Alessandro Saporita-Clark on 0161 832 4036, email Mike@kenworthys.co.uk, or Alessandro@kenworthys.co.uk.